PaySmarter

Methodology · Last updated: November 2026

How estimated net value is calculated

Every PaySmarter card review shows a single dollar figure: estimated first-year net value. Here's the formula behind it.

The short answer

Estimated first-year net value = signup bonus value (CAD) + earned rewards on a $30,000 typical Canadian spend profile − annual fee (waived to $0 if first-year-free). Bonus is valued at realistic Canadian redemption rates, not issuer-marketed rates.

The formula

Net value formula

Estimated first-year net value = Signup bonus (CAD) + Earned rewards (CAD) − Annual fee (CAD, waived if First Year Free).

Spend assumptions

Earned rewards are computed against a typical Canadian household spend profile of ~$30,000/year split across groceries, dining, transit, gas, recurring bills and 'other'. We weight each card's category multipliers against that mix.

How we value points

We value welcome bonuses at the Standard value published in The Points Standard Index (November 1, 2026 release) — what an informed, ordinary Canadian can realistically get from each program.

  • Aeroplan points: 1.9 cents per point.
  • Amex Membership Rewards: 1.9 cents per point.
  • RBC Avion points: 1.6 cents per point.
  • British Airways Avios: 1.6 cents per point.
  • CIBC Aventura points: 1.25 cents per point.
  • Scene+ points and WestJet points: 1 cent per point.
  • Cashback: face value (1 cent per cent).
  • Marriott Bonvoy points: 0.9 cents per point.
  • BMO Rewards points: 0.67 cents per point.
  • TD Rewards points: 0.5 cents per point.

Independent benchmarks, not issuer marketing

Issuers often quote point values higher than most Canadians realistically achieve. We use an independent Canadian index instead and review our figures when it changes.

Rent and recurring-bill adjustments

When a card's best play involves routing rent through Chexy, Neobanc or Casa, we add a separate 'estimated rent rewards' line that accounts for the platform fee. The headline net value figure assumes a baseline spend profile only — rent rewards are additive.

FAQ

Common questions

Because issuers quote the gross bonus at their own valuation rate. We subtract the annual fee, value points at realistic Canadian redemption rates, and only count rewards a typical user will actually earn.

No — the spend profile is a calibration baseline. Most cards still beat their fee at $15,000–$20,000 of annual spend, especially when rent is routed through a compatible platform.

Found this useful? Share it with someone who pays rent or bills.

Related Guides